Midnight Murder Club Game Review

Murder, Masks, and Mayhem

Ever imagined getting stuck in a pitch-black mansion where every sound could be your last? Midnight Murder Club brings that exact nightmare to life—with a mix of sneaky stealth, wild shootouts, and some seriously shady deception.

The concept had me hooked right away. Dark rooms, flashlights, revolvers, creepy masks—what could possibly go wrong? Add in the option to play with friends, and it sounded like the perfect setup for a fun (and slightly terrifying) game night.

But here’s the catch: it’s still in early access. So, the big question is—is it worth the price right now?

First Time in the Mansion

Firing up the game, I expected an intense vibe and fast action. The clean, minimalist menu sets the mood, and you can jump into a match pretty quickly.

But there was one annoying hiccup—you need a PlayStation Network account even if you’re playing on PC. Not a huge deal, but still kind of unnecessary.

Once the game starts? Total chaos. You’re in total darkness, with only flashlights cutting through the void and footsteps coming from everywhere. It’s like being dropped straight into a horror film.

Then—BANG. First gunshot. Someone screams, someone laughs, someone’s already dead. It’s unpredictable, messy, and kind of amazing.

Core Chaos: The Gameplay Loop

This isn’t your typical shooter. Midnight Murder Club is all about surviving in the dark, where hearing and deception matter just as much as aim.

The basics are simple. You’ve got a flashlight—use it, and you’re exposed. Don’t, and you’ll probably walk straight into a wall (or worse).

Your only weapon? A revolver. Six shots, slow reload. Every bullet counts, and one wrong move can mean game over.

What really makes things fun is the proximity voice chat. You can whisper to teammates, mess with enemies, or just creep someone out for fun. It adds a whole new layer of tension.

There are a few different modes: standard free-for-all, team deathmatch, and Wildcard Mode—which throws in random rules for pure chaos.

And the Guest Pass is a great feature. One player can invite five friends to play for free. It’s a blast with a group—but definitely not as fun solo.

Atmosphere That Pulls You In

What really sets Midnight Murder Club apart is the mood. It nails that creepy, “someone’s watching me” feeling.

The graphics are simple but stylish. The gothic mansion looks great, and the lighting/shadows play a big role in how you move and hide.

The sound design is killer—every footstep, gunshot, and whispered voice adds to the tension. Even hearing your own character breathe can make your skin crawl.

And when someone whispers in your ear through voice chat and you’re not sure if it’s a friend or a murderer? Yeah, that hits different.

Maps, Balance, and Room to Grow

Right now, there’s only one map—the mansion. It’s cool, but after a while, you’ll know every hallway and hiding spot. Some variety would be nice.

There’s not much in the way of progression. No unlockable, no skins. It doesn’t ruin the game, but adding rewards could give players more to work toward.

Some mechanics still need tweaking. “Kill stealing” is a thing, and the map can feel too big if the lobby isn’t full.

Wildcard Mode helps keep things fresh, but it’s a little unbalanced at times. Still, it’s probably the most fun mode right now.

Smooth or Sketchy?

Surprisingly, the game runs really well for something in early access. No major bugs, smooth performance, and matchmaking is quick.

That said, the PSN login requirement is a common complaint—especially for PC players. Some folks run into login issues, which is frustrating.

Team balancing isn’t always great either, but the core net code is solid, and you won’t be fighting lag most of the time.

$20 for One Map—Fair or Fail?

It’s $20 on Steam. For one map and limited content, that might feel a little pricey.

But the Guest Pass changes the game—you only need one buyer to get six people playing. That makes it way more worth it, especially for friend groups.

No microtransactions (yet), and if the devs keep it that way, that’s a big win. But if more content doesn’t drop soon, they might need to rethink the pricing model—or go free-to-play.

The Verdict: Worth the Hype?

Midnight Murder Club is a blast—especially with friends. It’s chaotic, tense, and totally unique. The mechanics are smart, the voice chat adds a spooky twist, and it’s got serious potential.

Is it perfect? Not yet. But if you love a little madness with your multiplayer, it’s definitely worth checking out.

If you like this review and want to see more, you can click here.  My snapchat is Cara_lynn97. Twitter and Instagram are the same. I stream on twitch multiple days a week! Be sure to follow me to see the live playthroughs of games and anything else I might do and post online.